VenturianTale Wiki

Jimmy Casket

2,879pages on
this wiki
Add New Page
Comments980 Share
Jimmy Casket
Jimmy as seen in The Sims 4
Gender Male
Played by Jordan Frye
Status Unknown (formerly dormant personality;given new body, possibly deceased)
Position/Rank World's Most Renowned Murderer (Self-proclaimed), Dinosaur hunter
Nationality American
Age 24

Possibly 29 (Werewolf Mod)

Group N/A
Weapon Military/talking Knife, sometimes a gun
Gmod MURDER Siblings 4-Player Multiplayer! (Garry's Mod)23:42

Gmod MURDER Siblings 4-Player Multiplayer! (Garry's Mod)

First appearance, unnamed
Murder "JIMMY CASKET!" - Gmod Murder Siblings 321:54

Murder "JIMMY CASKET!" - Gmod Murder Siblings 3.

First Identified as Jimmy Casket, first appearance of Abomination Form
"My name... is Jimmy Casket! I'm the world's most renowned murderer! I'm gonna put ya... in a casket! 'Cause my name is Jimmy Casket!"
Jimmy Casket
Jimmy Casket is an insane mass murderer played by Jordan Frye and is the alternate personality of Johnny Ghost and Gregory and the tertiary main antagonist of Venturiantale. He was first introduced in the first episode of Murder, but his name wasn't revealed until the third episode. In game Jimmy is outright with his insanity, which usually gives him away. He always asks people if they want to know his secret before telling and/or killing said person(s). The results of "His Secret" force Jimmy into drastic situations.

Sometimes the psychopath just stands there to creep everybody out. If he kills someone he states he is "freeing them of their mortal body... with a knife". He is very skilled with a blade, but when necessary he is shown often using a MSG in the Raptor Player Model mod, easily killing others with more dangerous weaponry like guns. It could be possible that Jimmy is not human, as he has shown to turn into a humanoid abomination (a gmod stalker), with strange telepathic powers and even shown to temporarily possess and speak through others, Including Vahl Aradur and Cywren Caster. Jimmy Casket may also be aligning himself with Maxwell Acachalla to haunt the gang. He commonly asks if they want to know his secret even if he's not the murderer.

He also runs the Creepypasta College (aka mental institution), and will kill students on a whim. Sally lives at this college. His trademark line (which pretty much sums him up) is simply to yell "Stab stab stab!!" As a popular fan favorite among many, this character in the Acachalla Universe roleplay, Jimmy Casket as appeared or been referenced in other LPs as well. He, as well as Johnny Ghost, have Gerontophobia, the fear of old men, as each of them are scared of the Toilet Toucher.

When Johnny Ghost found out about his dark side he tried to free Casket and make him a seperate person with Dipper Pines' lab equipment, the game crashed before we could see what happened so it is unknown if it worked. In Gmod GRAVITY FALLS DIPPER Mod 2, it was revealed that the machine had in fact separated Ghost and Casket, only for Jimmy to go into a coma and Johnny to have blurred memories of the experience. Dipper's evil double described Jimmy as a manifestation of Johnny's dark side which had been awakened by Johnny seeing "the Other Side". When he returned to find out what happened, Johnny Ghost inadvertently awakened Jimmy Casket by activating the same machine that separated them.

Jimmy's body is seen mounted on a wall in the Mystery Shack's final appearance and it is implied that Dipper has killed him.

Since then Ghost has occasionally said "do you wanna know my secret?", suggesting that Ghost is not entirely rid of Casket.

In the horse mod video PIE recieved a warning from an unknown entity, this warning showed visions of Maddie Friend, Darth Calculus, Luigi, Jimmy Casket's "monster form", and the death of Colon's father.

Jimmy has since appeared in a death match with Mario and Barry Bee Benson, using the thousand degree knife in said death match.

he also appeared in some other videos since then even without saying anything and just murdering and laughing, most of the time it is confirmed by johnny that he blacked out and then saw the one he was seeing before, dead.


After a long absence, he appeared in the Neighbor goes to McDonald's video after Ghost changes to his ultimate form.He was also mentioned as being created by the Housekeeper in this video.


Casket has a sociopathic personality and takes immense pleasure from killing people, as well as creeping them out with his maniacal laugh. He is shown to not be very bright however, erroneously believing he can take on a fully-grown Tyrannosaurus single-handedly, and on separate occasions taking on both Freddie and the entire Acachalla family after they had been turned into raptors. He also has immense fears of toilets, old men, and birds.

Jimmy seems to crave attention and often uses his maniacal tactics to get it. Often being the person of interest in an encounter. Casket can use his innate creepiness as well as a knife if he can. Even if he is weaponless, he can still terrify armed police and other murderers. Questioning if said murderers are truly a threat compared to him. However this has also proved to be a weakness of his, as it leaves casket closed minded on murdering and doing creepy things. So when someone isn't intimidated by him, or can attack him while he's distracted he's rather vulnerable. His closed mindedness also leaves him stunned and guessing when fighting unpredictable foes like the toilet toucher.


Maxwell Acachalla

Jimmy appears to both know and be very close with Maxwell Acachalla. The reasoning for this is unclear, but they have teamed up with each other. While they haven't actually had a conversation with one another, we are aware of them being close or at least tolerating one another long enough to stalk fellow victims. This alliance was short lived however, when (a possibly unbeknownst) Jimmy kills Maxwell whist he possesses Billy. Maxwell was shown to have taken this personally as he personally kills Casket a few episodes later.

Johnny Ghost/Gregory

"Is that... No, it's not! It's Jimmy Casket! He's come back to haunt me! Jimmy Casket! He's all around! I can't... He's in my head! I can hear him! He's-he's... He wants to show me his secret... Guys! Guys... I can't... I can't... His secret! Do you guys wanna know it? Do you guys wanna know his secret? DO YOU WANNA KNOW!? *indistinct, laughs* Jimmy Casket!"
Johnny Ghost
Gmod SCARY UNDERGROUND Co-Op Horror Map! (Garry's Mod)17:53

Gmod SCARY UNDERGROUND Co-Op Horror Map! (Garry's Mod)


Main article: Gregory & Johnny Ghost

Jimmy Casket is the subconscious alter ego of Paranormal Investigators Extraordinaire co-founder Johnny Ghost, and both are alternate personalities of Gregory. Whether Casket is a separate entity from Ghost/Gregory, or actually part of his psyche, is left open to interpretation, though there are several videos that hint both ways. Casket first surfaces during Gregory's childhood, around the same time as the appearance of Cardboard Friend, during which time he spent several months missing, first evading the police, and then being sent to a mental institution, which is where Casket (and possibly Gregory, if he had not been completely subsumed already) subsided and Ghost's new personality was "born".

It would be several years before Casket would return. In January 2014, during the Gmod SCARY UNDERGROUND Co-Op Horror Map! (Garry's Mod) episode, Casket, in cahoots with Maxwell Acachalla to trap Ghost, Billy, Sally and Gertrude, took a hold on Ghost's mind and held on for two years, during which Ghost would frequently lapse back into Casket's personality. Though Johnny Toast helped Ghost through it and Casket's reappearances have lessened to almost none as of 2015, there is always the fear that he would return.

Since Casket's first reappearance, Ghost's memories have been altered so that he has no recollection of Jimmy Casket or Gregory. He also seems to "black out" when Casket takes over (though he seemed to regain some memory of this during his time in the Dream Zone).

In 2016, Dipper Pines, in an attempt to purge Casket from Ghost's system, unintentionally gave Casket a corporeal form. Casket has (debatably) not been seen since, and it is possible he was pulled through the portal beneath the Mystery Shack. When Ghost later returns to the Mystery Shack with Toast, Casket's body is seen mounted on the wall, suggesting Dipper found and killed him.

Jackson (Child Services)

Jackson is believed by some to be one of Jimmy's alternate personalities.


Jimmy interacts with Sally very few times (so far). The first time when she asks him if he has waffles and he says he does. He tells her to get into his van, but is interrupted. A little later, he tells Sally he will never give her waffles and, in a fit of rage, Sally kills him. Sally may be the only other character capable of scaring Jimmy Casket, as both can be murderous, but it's more random with Sally.  The possible second time is during hide-and-seek, when Sally is in the attic, Jimmy is trying to get her and she's crying for her life. Sally is much more scared of him now, when she isn't crazy and has nothing to defend herself with.  A third encounter is when Jimmy is murdering them all as dinosaurs.  No direct interaction other than him killing her with the very stare of his eyes. The fourth time is when he killed Toilet Toucher and asked her how she and Slenderman are doing. It was also revealed he killed ALL of her family, except for Sally Betty Jessica, and her uncle, Uncle Charlie, who came back from the dead. Later in the video he kills Uncle Charlie. Sally occasionally lives in the mental institute Jimmy runs.

Johnny Toast

While an interaction between these two characters has not been seen, it has been shown that Toast is at least somewhat aware of Jimmy Casket's presence within Ghost's mind. Johnny Toast goes great lengths avoiding discussion about Casket. Refusing to ponder the possibility of Casket's return even within his mind. When Johnny Ghost seemed to be having a Casket moment, Toast quickly suggested that ghost take his pills. Whether Johnny Toast knows of Jimmy through a personal account or was merely warned about his partners split personality is unknown.

Vahl Aradur

Though they don't interact, it seems that Jimmy is able to somehow get into Vahl's mind. Killing several people (luckily they were bad guys and not innocent civilians) while being possessed, there is no telling how much he can control her actions though it only seems to happen when she's angry/vengeful, such as when Lydia died. Luckily Vahl has been Jimmy free as of now. Jimmy seems the equivalent to a puppet-master in this aspect.

Cywren Caster

Jimmy seems to have the same control over Cywren as he did Vahl, but she hasn't had an episode of Casket taking control for a long time.

Jeff the Killer

When Jeff went to the teacher the teacher soon was possessed by Jimmy Casket and said "Wanna know my secret?" This immediately scared Jeff into leaving the class room, showing that Jimmy is more terrifying than even Jeff himself. Then Isaac said Jimmy Casket should be a part of Creepypasta.  Jeff does go to the college run by Johnny Ghost, he never thought Johnny Ghost was also Jimmy Casket.

Toilet Toucher

The Toilet Toucher appears to be Jimmy Casket's mortal enemy as well as someone he fears. In Gmod EEVEE POKEMON Playermodels! he is more intent on killing the Toilet Toucher than any other person he's met. He seems to fear being locked in a bathroom alone due to Toilet Toucher's teleporting abilities with toilets.

When bring victims to a bathroom to be killed by the toilet toucher, Jimmy was surprised to see them come out alive and happy. Only for Jimmy to be murdered when he mimic their actions. With Sally theorizing that the toilet toucher only had a specific grudge against Jimmy at the time.

Tommy Casket

Tommy Casket is Jimmy Casket's father from his days as Gregory. The only thing Jimmy might have inherited from his father was a gold watch that was supposedly caskets grandfathers, either way it meant little to him as heisted only to lure a victim.

Princeton Quagmire

Princeton Quagmire has never met Casket, but he once turned into him out of nowhere and shot someone.Jimmy was recently confirmed by Venturian in the Dipper rag doll video to be Johnny Ghost's dark side and not a demon possessing him, meaning Quagmire might be another personality of Ghost/Casket/Gregory/Jackson.

Fred Spooker

Jimmy once killed Spooker after he annoyed Johnny Ghost. However this was later revealed to be a dream.

Donald Donnie

Jimmy killed Donald after he annoyed Johnny Ghost.


Jimmy Casket's main weapon is his bloody knife, which he uses to murder people. Though, he is still very creepy even when he doesn't have a knife to fight with. He is also shown to have some skill with a gun, as he has used it to kill off fellow murderers. He has been shown to kill whoever he wants, with whatever he has. He is also able to use guns to kill dinosaurs, which is only revealed in the Dinosaur Playermodel video. Jimmy Casket sometimes uses other people's fear as his weapon. He can also use a strange blade which says "Stab stab stab!" on it's own.but if you were to face him in combat its either you kill him or get killed.The talking blade itself has been made into a downloadable weapon in the Steam Worshop, and Venturian has used it on multiple occasions. Primary fire causes it to say "Stab stab stab!", secondary fire causes it to say "Hey, you wanna know my secret?".He also as been known to weild an axe and a machete as shown when he killed the Left 4 Dead Survivors.He has also been seen weilding 1000 degree knife.

Jimmy Casket Fanfictions

VenturianTale Character Tournament

He was the victor of the 2014 Tournament, and returned in 2015.


The following is a list of people killed by Jimmy Casket, feel free to add any we may have missed


Jimmy Casket's Knife

The knife Casket uses in the Murder gamemode

  • "Hey! Do you want to know my secret?!?!?"
  • "JIMMY CASKET!!!!!!"
  • "You want to have some fun?!?!"
  • "Let's have a Party!"
  • "No one wants to hear my secret!"
  • "My secret is, I don't know how to read!"
  • "You wanna know my se- AH!  You got a secret!  You got a bigger secret!"
  • "Do you ever have the sudden urge to...bite someone?"
  • "I'd like to bite someone right about now."
  • "I use their flesh as a stress toy!"
  • "I'm so close...I can smell you!"
  • "Oh, apparently, I showed ya too hard! Don't worry, I'll be gental next time."
  • "Oh, it seems you're at your dead end....LITERALLY!!  Hahahaha!"
  • "Don't wanna run do ya?  It only makes it better for me!"
  • "So easy!  Easy as a pumpkin pie..."
  • "Do ya wanna know my secret Johnny!? (Most likely a reference to him being Johnny Ghost)"
  • "My mother was a man!"
  • "Uh-oh, you guys are in trouble!  Here comes Jimmy Casket!"
  • "I guess Jimmy Casket, strikes again!  Hahahaha- uh-oh, I struck too hard."
  • "One of us is a murderer, the other is an insane maniac, but who is truly a threat?"
  • "I only freed her mind from her mortal body.  With a knife."
  • "Ow.  Someone scratched my back with a knife. I hate it when that happens."
  • "She dropped the vase like I dropped the base!"
  • "She dropped me like I dropped the base!"
  • "Jimmy Casket's good with a knife, not so good with flack-hard jackets."
  • "I am horribly terrified, and have a phobia for macaroni!"
  • "I'm terrified of macaroni and cheese. I have dreams about it! It comes in and eats me! It's very ironic..."
  • "You wanna know my... Oh... Nice Shot!" (Jimmys catchphrase interrupted when he is shot and mortally wounded)
  • "Stab stab stab! Stab stab stab!"
  • "Guess what's going in your gut!? Stab stab stab!"
  • "No one ever listens to a guy with a secret!!!!"
  • "Let me show you my friend his name is Knifey,oops i guess i showed you a little too hard!"
  • "What's wrong? Are you afraid of little old me? Stab stab stab!"
  • "You died, I'm alive! Blood Blood Blood!"
  • "If you're a doctor, you shouldn't be scared of surgery, huh?"
  • "You'll be feeling my knife soon. Hahaha!"
  • "The moment you step out of that room, I'm coming..."
  • "Oh, yes, the stabbing is good!"
  • "Oh, this should be good!"
  • "Un im lika legolas up in here."
  • "Ahh are you afraid of little old me?"
  • "Come get some!"
  • "But first, I have to talk to your friend! AHAHAHAH!"
  • "I'm going to put ya in a casket 'cause my name's Jimmy Casket!"


  • It is assumed Jimmy lived in the insane asylum Johnny Ghost went to.
  • Jimmy Casket is probably the creepiest of the characters, Sally coming in second as she has never scared a Creepypasta member as Jimmy has.
  • Jimmy Casket is so scary he has easily terrified paranormal investigator Johnny Ghost, his own alter ego.  He therefore terrified his more sane self.
  • Jimmy is not limited to gmod, as he has temporally possessed Vahl several times. Although not long enough to attack someone who wasn't an enemy.He has also appeared in Left4Dead.
  • It is possible that Jimmy may have known Johnny Ghost prior to becoming a killer, as Johnny seemed to know about him. It was later revealed that they are one and the same.
  • Johnny Ghost IS Jimmy Casket, though Johnny was unaware of it. He now is aware of it and in one of the Creepypasta videos even tried to stop himself from changing into Jimmy Casket after he was stabbed, although he did eventually change. However, in the Batman Horror map, when Billy said, "Jimmy Casket's gonna break out." after Johnny showed signs of becoming Jimmy again, he replied with, "Who's Jimmy Casket?" This is because Jimmy decided to erase his alter-egos' memory of being him from his subconscious, after realizing that Johnny may become a problem after Johnny resisted turning into him in the Creepypasta video.
  • He is so creepy, even the infamous Jeff the Killer is intimidated by him.
  • Though Gertrude asks Papa if Johnny's transformations are like Papa's, he didn't confirm it.
  • Johnny became Jimmy when the Acachalla family refused to pay and threatened him. It could be assumed he transforms whenever someone displeases him/threatens him, or when he gets stressed out.
  • The extent of his powers is unknown, and he is clearly immortal.  He shrugs off getting killed and plots revenge.
  • Jimmy and Sally may in fact be related.
  • Jimmy/Johnny may be Billy's true father.
  • His favorite color is red, and he prefers onions to 'the yellow condiment.'
  • He and Jeff will keep saying "Stab stab stab" back and forth to one another
  • He runs the Creepypasta College/mental institution.
  • He is apperently a happy mother .
  • He claims to be a world renouned dinosaur hunter.
  • He is part of a quartet; Johnny Ghost, Gregory, Jackson, and himself. They're all the same person.
  • He seems to have an interest in Pokemon.
  • He knows about Sally's relationship with Slenderman. Most likely because Slendy went to his school.
  • He fears the Toilet Toucher. It is unknown why.
  • He is probaly a unusophobic, afraid of turning into/being someone different. It's unknown if he knows he has the problem, or if he has it at all.
  • He apparently has a cousin named Jeremy, this may be referring to Jeremy Acachalla or Jeremy from the Midas Cannon mod video. (MINECRAFT Murder 6)
  • He also calls his knife, "Knifey".
  • He serves as an enemy in Five Nights at Venturiantale during Night 8, replacing Bethany during that night.


Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.